CGY-EDM Attempt 2

[thehockeyist]

Accept.

[Ottawa Senators GM]

I'm fine with this

[Montreal Canadiens GM]

Still think both the St. Louis and Vegas first is too much. Take out St. Louis' first and I think this is fine

[Vegas Golden Knights GM]

Considering the last deal that Edmonton tried to make it doesn't seem like he is trying to go for it. Thus trading a potential top 5 pick for a 36 year old dman makes no sense. Reject.

[Calgary Flames GM]

That division is extremely close so it wouldn't take much for the value of that pick to be a playoff pick

[Calgary Flames GM]

Dec 11, 2020 18:53:57 GMT -8 Vegas Golden Knights GM said:

Considering the last deal that Edmonton tried to make it doesn't seem like he is trying to go for it. Thus trading a potential top 5 pick for a 36 year old dman makes no sense. Reject.

He is going for it. He changed his mind on the Kilorn trade. I'm honestly not sure what he was thinking there because he told me he's going for playoffs and wants to keep Killorn

[Philadelphia Flyers GM]

STL pick is 2nd last. Still no good. Reject

[Vegas Golden Knights GM]

Dec 11, 2020 18:55:17 GMT -8 Calgary Flames GM said:

Dec 11, 2020 18:53:57 GMT -8 Vegas Golden Knights GM said:

Considering the last deal that Edmonton tried to make it doesn't seem like he is trying to go for it. Thus trading a potential top 5 pick for a 36 year old dman makes no sense. Reject.

He is going for it. He changed his mind on the Kilorn trade. I'm honestly not sure what he was thinking there because he told me he's going for playoffs and wants to keep Killorn

And tomorrow he can be rebuilding again. 

[Montreal Canadiens GM]

Dec 11, 2020 18:54:23 GMT -8 Calgary Flames GM said:

That division is extremely close so it wouldn't take much for the value of that pick to be a playoff pick

Well then people have got to choose how they value picks. Last week Edmonton's pick was being valued like it's a surefire top 5 pick, so why would St. Louis be any different?

[Calgary Flames GM]

Bruh then have a talk with Edmonton, seriously. I mainly just want Kovalchuk and Graves and some picks to make up for losing my captain and best defender. Having my trades rejected cus of the volatility of another gm is pretty frustrating lol

[Colorado Avalanche GM]

I agree No need for that STL 1st. Rejected. Giordano won't improve his team that much

[Montreal Canadiens GM]

Dec 11, 2020 19:00:04 GMT -8 Calgary Flames GM said:

Bruh then have a talk with Edmonton, seriously. I mainly just want Kovalchuk and Graves and some picks to make up for losing my captain and best defender. Having my trades rejected cus of the volatility of another gm is pretty frustrating lol

It's on you to make a fair trade as well. Just because Edmonton will accept bad offers doesn't mean you just throw them at him - they're going to get rejected lol. If anything submitting like 4 different trades says that both GMs can't judge what's fair and what's not, no matter who's winning the trade.

[Calgary Flames GM]

Lol last thread you guys just wanted me to replace the Chicago pick with VGK and then when I do that it gets rejected anyway

[Montreal Canadiens GM]

Dec 11, 2020 19:03:20 GMT -8 Calgary Flames GM said:

Lol last thread you guys just wanted me to replace the Chicago pick with VGK and then when I do that it gets rejected anyway

Only Ottawa said that. Canes Avs and myself all said 2 1sts was too much.

[thehockeyist]

Yes, I am trying to improve! I may have made terrible decisions, but I am trying to fix that.

Here's an oath. I, TheHockeyist, hereby declare that I am trying to shoot for the playoffs.

[Carolina Hurricanes GM]

Dec 11, 2020 19:05:59 GMT -8 thehockeyist said:

Yes, I am trying to improve! I may have made terrible decisions, but I am trying to fix that.

Here's an oath. I, TheHockeyist, hereby declare that I am trying to shoot for the playoffs.

You’re 3rd in the Pacific right now. After that Jarry trade your team has been on fire. There’s something to be said for the right chemistry.

Plus, you have ALL those picks just in case. I don’t think trading them for an often hurt, 37 year old Giordano is worth it man. 

He WILL be downgraded something, no matter what

FWIW, I’ll still accept if you take out the STL pick 

[Ottawa Senators GM]

Dec 11, 2020 18:55:20 GMT -8 Philadelphia Flyers GM said:

STL pick is 2nd last.

I did not realize this, I thought they were in a playoff position.


At the risk of sounding like Kruze, just cause Gio's old doesn't mean he has no value, he's still a 90, and probably a high 80s for the next few seasons. Worth two later firsts plus something, surely (though STL's 1st isn't currently a later one, which I didn't realize).