Post by Carolina Hurricanes GM on Oct 12, 2021 12:59:06 GMT -8
This is the vote for GM of the ERA
I didn’t include the quick sim in the totals part for time reasons, but feel free to factor that in for this
I’ll give a little case for each one, feel free to plead your own
bigstinkypoop and the
1 Cup, 8 Awards, 56.6% in the Playoffs, 8 players Drafted played NHL, Solid Trades
Miiko and the
1 Cup, 8 Awards, 31 playoff wins, 67.3% in playoffs, the Dorofeyev trade, Provorov.
Retro and the
25 playoff wins, 4 appearances in 4 seasons as GM, 4 Awards, Traded for McDavid, Gaudreau, Soshnikov. Drafted and grew Poltapov/ Prokopenko
Cranker8989 and the
2nd most wins/points by a GM, 3 playoff appearances, S5 Metro Division Winners
redmark91 and the
2 Cups counting quick sim, 61.5% in playoffs (not counting QS) 3 Awards
fatballsack and the
4th most wins/points by GM, Most Playoff Wins by GM, 1 SCF appearance, Traded for MacKinnon
maxbrown and the
Most Wins/Points by a GM, 8 Awards Won, Grew Caufield, Bourgault. The Bourgault trade, S2 Atlantic Divison Winners
snaggs and the
6th Most Wins/Points by GM, 5th Most Playoff Wins by GM, 9 Awards Won, Traded for Malkin, Ekblad, Denisenko. Grew Denisenko
steinkej4 and the
7th most Playoff Wins by GM, 55.5% in playoffs, 3 appearances in 5 years. Lots of solid trades
sandman and the
5th Most Wins/Points by GM, 3 Awards, 2 Calders, S3 Atlantic Division Winners. Developed Amirov
oldgreg and the van:
Seasons 1-4. 6th Most Playoff Wins, 1 SCF appearance, S4 Pacific Divison Winners, 3/4 playoff appearances, 5 Awards, Drafted Developed Trizokov, and Podkolzin
Joubran13 and the
Seasons 1-3 and 5. 4th Most Points by Team, 3/4 Playoff appearances, 14 Awards won, S3 Presidents Trophy and Pacific Divison Winners. Traded for Crosby, Kane, Draisaitl and Vasilevski.
bluejaybich and the
Seasons 2-5. 3rd most Wins by GM in playoffs, Playoff appearances in 4/4. S3 and S4 Metropolitan Divison Winners. 1 SCF appearance. 4 Awards Won
I didn’t include the quick sim in the totals part for time reasons, but feel free to factor that in for this
I’ll give a little case for each one, feel free to plead your own
bigstinkypoop and the
1 Cup, 8 Awards, 56.6% in the Playoffs, 8 players Drafted played NHL, Solid Trades
Miiko and the
1 Cup, 8 Awards, 31 playoff wins, 67.3% in playoffs, the Dorofeyev trade, Provorov.
Retro and the
25 playoff wins, 4 appearances in 4 seasons as GM, 4 Awards, Traded for McDavid, Gaudreau, Soshnikov. Drafted and grew Poltapov/ Prokopenko
Cranker8989 and the
2nd most wins/points by a GM, 3 playoff appearances, S5 Metro Division Winners
redmark91 and the
2 Cups counting quick sim, 61.5% in playoffs (not counting QS) 3 Awards
fatballsack and the
4th most wins/points by GM, Most Playoff Wins by GM, 1 SCF appearance, Traded for MacKinnon
maxbrown and the
Most Wins/Points by a GM, 8 Awards Won, Grew Caufield, Bourgault. The Bourgault trade, S2 Atlantic Divison Winners
snaggs and the
6th Most Wins/Points by GM, 5th Most Playoff Wins by GM, 9 Awards Won, Traded for Malkin, Ekblad, Denisenko. Grew Denisenko
steinkej4 and the
7th most Playoff Wins by GM, 55.5% in playoffs, 3 appearances in 5 years. Lots of solid trades
sandman and the
5th Most Wins/Points by GM, 3 Awards, 2 Calders, S3 Atlantic Division Winners. Developed Amirov
oldgreg and the van:
Seasons 1-4. 6th Most Playoff Wins, 1 SCF appearance, S4 Pacific Divison Winners, 3/4 playoff appearances, 5 Awards, Drafted Developed Trizokov, and Podkolzin
Joubran13 and the
Seasons 1-3 and 5. 4th Most Points by Team, 3/4 Playoff appearances, 14 Awards won, S3 Presidents Trophy and Pacific Divison Winners. Traded for Crosby, Kane, Draisaitl and Vasilevski.
bluejaybich and the
Seasons 2-5. 3rd most Wins by GM in playoffs, Playoff appearances in 4/4. S3 and S4 Metropolitan Divison Winners. 1 SCF appearance. 4 Awards Won